So which President # should he be?

I was listening to some sports radio show the other day.. I never listen to sports but I heard them having a discussion about the President #s and so I kept listening..

anyways, the one guy was saying that Obama should be Pres. # 43 not 44

and the other guys said no he is and should be 44

so the 2nd guy explains that 1 President served twice- not consecutively- so he counts as 2 numbers and thats why theres 44 now.

the 1st guy says no the one that served twice is only ONE man so he should only count as one President total.

the 2nd guy is also saying that 44 men have taken the oath and so theres 44 Presidents.
but the other guy is saying yeah, but one of those 44 was still one man.

so, I see both sides..

never thought about it before..

can you imagine.. you were the Pres. twice and you say, yeah I was President 18 and 21 (I dont know what #s he really was)
how funny.

wondering what others think it should be.. 43 or 44?